« Why you cannot make people better by telling them what is good »
Un article de Ulf Hlobil intitulé « Why you cannot make people better by telling them what is good« , paru dans le European Journal of Philosophy.
So‐called optimists about moral testimony argue, against pessimists, that, ceteris paribus, we ought to accept and act in accordance with trustworthy, pure moral testimony. I argue that even if we grant this, we need to explain why moral testimony cannot make us more virtuous. I offer an explanation that appeals to the fact that we cannot share inferential abilities via testimony. This explanation is compatible with the core commitments of optimism, but it also allows us to see what is right about pessimism.